Mrs Brown

Posted 12 July 2005 in Screening log
“What I do I do for my Queen.”

Rating

1997 - UK

Director
John Madden

Starring
Judi Dench, Billy Connolly, Geoffrey Palmer, Antony Sher

This film appeals to the part of me sure to be engrossed throughout and brokenhearted ultimately in at least two ways. More obviously, the misunderstood and unconventional relationship. I become increasingly sensitive to the infinite ways in which love manifests itself, while the majority of society sees three well-defined and -differentiated categories. There is no place in most imaginations for a concept such as — let’s call it ‘passionate friendship,’ for loyalty and dependence and trust without the ties of blood or sex, without any evident commonalities of background or belief.

Secondly, I find I have great sympathy for the plight of the monarchy. Like The Lost Prince, Mrs Brown demonstrates the great toll being a national figurehead takes on private relationships and personal happiness — royalty are assumed to be somehow unlike their subjects, and eventually they become something inhuman. Duty, in the end, trumps desire and affinity — it’s a sacrifice I cannot imagine.

And I cannot imagine living with the knowledge that everyone around you owns a piece of you — despite all the power and adoration, having to refer to yourself invariably in the third person. Indeed, one of the most telling exchanges between Victoria and John comes when she finally and unconsciously drops this barrier after he attempts to resign his post:

Victoria The Queen forbids it — I cannot allow it, because I cannot live without you.

Such simple devotion becomes scandalous when every corner of society thinks it has an interest in it: other servants and advisors, slighted by her sudden preference for this ruffian; the royal family, jealous and prideful; parliament and PM Disraeli, sensing a political opportunity; the public, demanding her return to public life. John Brown quickly becomes the only person capable of bringing a smile to her face again, but she cannot seclude herself in the comfort of her estate in Scotland for long.

His obsession with her safety and willingness to sacrifice as much as she has no choice to for her eventually leads to perceived betrayal and separation. Her return to public life stabilizes the monarchy and satisfies the ‘greater good,’ but ensures her numbed isolation and his descent into madness.

It is an absorbing story and a fascinating relationship, each always challenging the other, by its very nature unsteady but grounded by something fundamental and desperate. This is the performance that should have won Judi Dench an Oscar, as she plays the now controlled, now collapsing monarch with sublety and sincerity. Billy Connolly — previously known to me only from the probably terrible (but I remember liking it when I was 8!) family sitcom Head of the Class — also shines as the boisterous and increasingly possessed man who simply lives to serve his Queen. It’s a poignant character study and revealing history lesson masterfully executed by all involved.

Quotations

Brown (holds up Christmas card; he has it memorized) From the Queen. “My lips may give a message better of Christmas love than even this letter. To my best friend JB, from his best friend VR.” Best friend! She means it!

Victoria In truth, I think I am someone who can only feel thngs when they are alive to me — and for that reason I know I do not have a subtle mind.

Victoria I have noticed of late my feelings of grief are not so strong, and I find myself feeling more — on the comfort of living friends, friends close to me now.

A settled resignation is more lasting proof of affection than active grief. If the good Lord sees fit to bring one into contact with congenial fellow beings, one need not analyze one’s reactions too deeply.

Victoria (after Brown attempts to resign) The Queen forbids it — I cannot allow it, because I cannot live without you. Without you I cannot find the strength to be who I must be. Please — (kisses his hand) — promise me you won’t let them send me back.
Brown (kisses her hand) I promise.

Brown What I do I do for my Queen.

Victoria I know I’ve not always been the loyal friend you deserve, John. And here even now I’m feeling desperate with the thought of losing you.
Brown Don’t be silly, woman.

 

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)


about
Lauren, 25, out-of-work librarian. At the moment, TLC is but a review blog and catalogue of my film-related perversions. I always plan to do more with it — and to one day step outside 30s Hollywood again. Who knows?


navigation
Films: All reviewed | Favorites
Actors: Profiles | Favorites
Directors: Profiles | Favorites
Screencap galleries
All films by year
2008 Viewing log


Screening Log
» The Great Lie 1941, Edmund Goulding
» In This Our Life 1942, John Huston
» The Crash 1932, William Dieterle
» Café Metropole 1937, Edward H Griffith
» Dodsworth 1936, William Wyler
» The Rich Are Always with Us 1932, Alfred E Green
» Lilly Turner 1933, William A Wellman
» Frisco Jenny 1932, William A Wellman
» Female 1933, Michael Curtiz
» Waterloo Bridge 1931, James Whale

Feedback
Café Metropole (1)
  • Laura: Have been enjoying catching up with your blog in recent days — your post on LILLY TURNER makes me want...
100 Favorite Films (5)
  • artgrl: great list, thank you.
The Great Lie (2)
  • Lauren: Au contraire, I love the idea of the potentials of artlessness. …And wish I had somewhere to go with...
  • Mango: Wonderful, an update. Cool spoiler device. It sounds like this strikes on the wonderful potentials artlessness...
In This Our Life (1)
  • John McElwee: I’ve just discovered you, spent the last hour reading “The Life Cinematic”, and let...

The Bookshelf
Currently reading
On the shelf
» Film library
» Complete library

links
» Allure
» Awards Daily
» Bright Lights Film Journal
» Cinemaniacal
» Cinemascope
» Cinema Talk
» Classic Cinema Online
» Collective Contemplations on Cinema
» Critical Culture
» Criticker
» Fataculture
» Film Comment
» Film Int
» Greenbriar Picture Shows
» House of Mirth & Movies
» If Charlie Parker Was a Gunslinger...
» Jump Cut
» Mango Grove
» Not Coming to a Theater Near You
» The Pagan Agenda
» Pop Matters
» Rants & Musings
» Reverse Shot
» Self-Styled Siren
» Senses of Cinema
» Shining a Light on the Forgotten Classics
» Sight & Sound
» Sin in Soft Focus
» TCM schedule
» They Shoot Pictures, Don't They?
» Through a Blog Darkly

Netflix
The Asphalt Jungle Under the Volcano Lifeboat The Most Dangerous Game The Good Fairy Persepolis 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days Belle Toujours 

Friend me