La Séparation

Posted 17 March 2007 in screencaps Screening log
“We might do one another in.”

Rating


1994 - France

Director
Claude Berri

Starring
Isabelle Huppert, Daniel Auteiul                       

This isn’t a case of a film being other than what I thought it’d be. But it is other than I’d have it be: I go in knowing it’s an 85-min drama about a woman’s infidelity in which we never see the other man, and which begins with the simple premise of her pulling her hand away when her partner reaches for it in a theater. I’d have it be a Bergman-via-Allen chamber drama.

Alas, no — from the start I’ll settle for glossy light verite. It is absorbing though not for depth or truth — aside from what the actors bring to it — but for a certain honest simplicity. Ultimately it seems we do not meet the other man because it isn’t really the story of a separation, but that story from the man’s point of view. If I have any direct critique to make it is that the film tries a bit too hard to sway one into siding with him, into the “message” that custody law sucks. This violates that honest simplicity that is the film’s real strength — and which anyway doesn’t amount to much. No, the film doesn’t amount to much but it is a satisfying watch.

I often find myself hedging between two ratings and choose up or down based on one specific little thing: in this case the film gets the bump up because (spoiler, LOL) he never makes out with the babysitter. Unless he does after the credits: the existential anomaly of being passed over by two dozen cabs in a row seemed to persuade him to walk back to one woman or the other. Oh well! The film satisfies but doesn’t leave me with burning questions.

Screencaps

 

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)


about
Lauren, 25, out-of-work librarian. At the moment, TLC is but a review blog and catalogue of my film-related perversions. I always plan to do more with it — and to one day step outside 30s Hollywood again. Who knows?


navigation
Films: All reviewed | Favorites
Actors: Profiles | Favorites
Directors: Profiles | Favorites
Screencap galleries
All films by year
2008 Viewing log


Screening Log
» Rachel Getting Married 2008, Jonathan Demme
» Elegy 2008, Isabel Coixet
» Jeopardy 1953, John Sturges
» 2 or 3 Things I Know About Her 1967, Jean-Luc Godard
» Appaloosa 2008, Ed Harris
» Belle toujours 2007, Manoel de Oliveira
» Duel in the Sun 1946, King Vidor
» Dragonwyck 1946, Joseph L Mankiewicz
» The Spiral Staircase 1945, Robert Siodmak
» The Man Who Knew Too Much 1934, Alfred Hitchcock

Feedback
The Great TLC Thanksgiving Taped-TCM Live-Blog Marathon Event! (15)
  • Mango: You have my full encouragement in the Capra/Lubitsch essay you want to write. Write it, please.
  • Lauren: Yeah, I finished it, but I was getting ready to go out simultaneously so not much blogging. I liked it, and...
  • Mango: Song of Songs is a broken disc. Unfortunate. Poor Anna Sten. I think I heard she was laughed at as...
  • Lauren: …I’M FUCKING SCREWED, tomorrow is Bette & Joan all day. I’ll never catch up.
100 Favorite Films (6)
  • christopher: Thanks for the list. I spend my time looking for something I haven’t seen or positive comments on...

The Bookshelf
Currently reading
On the shelf
» Film library
» Complete library

links
» Allure
» Awards Daily
» Bright Lights Film Journal
» Cinema Becomes Her
» Cinemaniacal
» Cinemascope
» Cinema Talk
» Classic Cinema Online
» Collective Contemplations on Cinema
» Critical Culture
» Criticker
» Fataculture
» Film Comment
» Film Int
» Greenbriar Picture Shows
» House of Mirth & Movies
» If Charlie Parker Was a Gunslinger...
» Jump Cut
» Kinovision
» Mango Grove
» Not Coming to a Theater Near You
» An Oval Portrait
» The Pagan Agenda
» Pop Matters
» Rants & Musings
» Reverse Shot
» Self-Styled Siren
» Senses of Cinema
» Shining a Light on the Forgotten Classics
» Sight & Sound
» Sin in Soft Focus
» Something Sweet, Something Tender
» They Shoot Pictures, Don't They?
» Through a Blog Darkly
» To Here Knows When

Netflix
In a Lonely Place Fallen Angel Jean Renoir: French Cancan Abraham's Valley I'm Going Home Genealogies of a Crime I'm Not There The Fallen Idol 

Friend me