Some notes on rating films

Posted 25 March 2008 in

My scale operates on the principle that I need more ratings to show how well I liked a film, and far fewer to show how much I did not like it. And really I need few rating distinctions at all: my thoughts & emotional response count for more. Almost all ratings are positive.

Exceptional: Essential viewing. [9-10/10]
An example of what I consider the best/most rewarding cinematic experience. Masterpiece or near-masterpiece.

Great: Highly recommended. [7.5-9/10]
Not quite the staggering, mind-blowing experience of a -rated film, but great cinema nonetheless. I never expect a film to be better than this.

Good: Recommended. [6-7/10]
A perfectly solid film. Not everyone will love it, but it is a fine example of its time/genre/&c. I appreciate it without being wild about it. I would recommend s and up to anyone.

Of interest: Recommended with caution. [5-6/10]
Some problematic aspects, but people with an interest in the genre/movement/director/&c should definitely check this out. Could be good but unremarkable, an interesting failure, or a quality film that does not resonate with me.

Mediocre: Not recommended. [4-5/10]
Bland or uninspired filmmaking, not very rewarding, but a decent way to pass the time.

Bad: Recommended against. [1-3/10]
This is my only negative rating. I watch so few bad films. They all deserve to be lumped together. There is no degree of badness. Bad is bad. Don’t bother with these!

Ie: NO STARS for bad films. ANY stars indicates some worth.

 

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)


navigation
About TLC
Films: All reviewed | Favorites
Actors: Profiles | Favorites
Directors: Profiles | Favorites
Screencap galleries
All films by year
2008 Viewing log


Screening Log
Waterloo Bridge 1931, James Whale
Red-Headed Woman 1932, Jack Conway
Millie 1931, John Francis Dillon
The Woman Accused 1933, Paul Sloane
So Big! 1932, William A Wellman
The Awful Truth 1937, Leo McCarey
Conquest 1937, Clarence Brown
It’s Love I’m After 1937, Archie Mayo
The Mad Miss Manton 1938, Leigh Jason
Algiers 1938, John Cromwell

Blog

A short digression on Charles Boyer…

Yes, I am endeared. I am, in fact, ensorceled. His inhumanly arched eyebrows, his little winks and half-smiles, and that ability to at once maintain full control of his material while shining the spotlight on his costar: yes, that is talent; yes, this is love. And no, Cluny Brown, it’s not just the cocktails giving you that persian cat feeling… I think we both know too well it has a bit to do with Mr Charles Boyer. Rawr.


Projects

Pre-Code Hollywood

» Waterloo Bridge 1931 James Whale
» Red-Headed Woman 1932 Jack Conway
» Millie 1931 John Francis Dillon
» The Woman Accused 1933 Paul Sloane
» So Big! 1932 William A Wellman

Previous & ongoing
30s Cinema
Maestresses
The Lubitsch Race

Five Favorites

In-transit romances

Nothing better suited to Hollywood romance than three weeks out of time, away from life, falling in love with a stranger, spending days idly and nights actively.


The Bookshelf
Currently reading
On the shelf

links
Allure
Awards Daily
Bright Lights Film Journal
Cinemaniacal
Cinema Talk
Classic Cinema Online
Collective Contemplations on Cinema
Critical Culture
Criticker
Fataculture
Film Comment
Film Int
Greenbriar Picture Shows
House of Mirth & Movies
If Charlie Parker Was a Gunslinger...
Jump Cut
Mango Grove
Not Coming to a Theater Near You
The Pagan Agenda
Pop Matters
Rants & Musings
Reverse Shot
Self-Styled Siren
Senses of Cinema
Shining a Light on the Forgotten Classics
Sight & Sound
Sin in Soft Focus
TCM schedule
They Shoot Pictures, Don't They?
Through a Blog Darkly

Netflix
The Divorcee / A Free Soul The Good Fairy Persepolis 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days Belle Toujours Lifeboat The Little Foxes Dancing Lady 

Friend me