Some notes on rating films

Posted 25 March 2008 in Screening log

My scale operates on the principle that I need more ratings to show how well I liked a film, and far fewer to show how much I did not like it. And really I need few rating distinctions at all: my thoughts & emotional response count for more. Almost all ratings are positive.

Exceptional: Essential viewing. [9-10/10]
An example of what I consider the best/most rewarding cinematic experience. Masterpiece or near-masterpiece.

Great: Highly recommended. [7.5-9/10]
Not quite the staggering, mind-blowing experience of a -rated film, but great cinema nonetheless. I never expect a film to be better than this.

Good: Recommended. [6-7/10]
A perfectly solid film. Not everyone will love it, but it is a fine example of its time/genre/&c. I appreciate it without being wild about it. I would recommend s and up to anyone.

Of interest: Recommended with caution. [5-6/10]
Some problematic aspects, but people with an interest in the genre/movement/director/&c should definitely check this out. Could be good but unremarkable, an interesting failure, or a quality film that does not resonate with me.

Mediocre: Not recommended. [4-5/10]
Bland or uninspired filmmaking, not very rewarding, but a decent way to pass the time.

Bad: Recommended against. [1-3/10]
This is my only negative rating. I watch so few bad films. They all deserve to be lumped together. There is no degree of badness. Bad is bad. Don’t bother with these!

Ie: NO STARS for bad films. ANY stars indicates some worth.

 

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)


about
Lauren, 25, out-of-work librarian. At the moment, TLC is but a review blog and catalogue of my film-related perversions. I always plan to do more with it — and to one day step outside 30s Hollywood again. Who knows?


navigation
Films: All reviewed | Favorites
Actors: Profiles | Favorites
Directors: Profiles | Favorites
Screencap galleries
All films by year
2008 Viewing log


Screening Log
» The Great Lie 1941, Edmund Goulding
» In This Our Life 1942, John Huston
» The Crash 1932, William Dieterle
» Café Metropole 1937, Edward H Griffith
» Dodsworth 1936, William Wyler
» The Rich Are Always with Us 1932, Alfred E Green
» Lilly Turner 1933, William A Wellman
» Frisco Jenny 1932, William A Wellman
» Female 1933, Michael Curtiz
» Waterloo Bridge 1931, James Whale

Feedback
Café Metropole (2)
  • Lauren: Judging by your love of pre-Codes, I think you’d definitely enjoy Lilly Turner and I definitely...
  • Laura: Have been enjoying catching up with your blog in recent days — your post on LILLY TURNER makes me want...
100 Favorite Films (5)
  • artgrl: great list, thank you.
The Great Lie (2)
  • Lauren: Au contraire, I love the idea of the potentials of artlessness. …And wish I had somewhere to go with...
  • Mango: Wonderful, an update. Cool spoiler device. It sounds like this strikes on the wonderful potentials artlessness...

The Bookshelf
Currently reading
On the shelf
» Film library
» Complete library

links
» Allure
» Awards Daily
» Bright Lights Film Journal
» Cinemaniacal
» Cinemascope
» Cinema Talk
» Classic Cinema Online
» Collective Contemplations on Cinema
» Critical Culture
» Criticker
» Fataculture
» Film Comment
» Film Int
» Greenbriar Picture Shows
» House of Mirth & Movies
» If Charlie Parker Was a Gunslinger...
» Jump Cut
» Mango Grove
» Not Coming to a Theater Near You
» The Pagan Agenda
» Pop Matters
» Rants & Musings
» Reverse Shot
» Self-Styled Siren
» Senses of Cinema
» Shining a Light on the Forgotten Classics
» Sight & Sound
» Sin in Soft Focus
» TCM schedule
» They Shoot Pictures, Don't They?
» Through a Blog Darkly

Netflix
The Asphalt Jungle Under the Volcano Lifeboat The Most Dangerous Game The Good Fairy Persepolis 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days Belle Toujours 

Friend me